Steve Thomas asked an interesting question recently, which prompted me to set down some things I had been thinking about. I have added a few comments here for those with a less mathematical background or a different location in the world, plus links.
The most essential point about teaching young children is to begin with what they already know about, and at least partially understand. Arithmetic must begin, then, with counting or measuring material things. The Montessori materials include a variety of such objects for shapes and counting. The Cuisenaire rods provide ten lengths in ten colors. (I like to supplement them with the notion of a colorless rod of length zero. Why is it colorless? For the same reason that you cannot divide by zero. Zero can be zero of anything. So it cannot be limited to one particular color.) Today we will talk about cutting circles or circular objects into slices of the same size and different colors.
On Tue, July 12, 2011 11:23 pm, Steve Thomas wrote:
> Looking for ideas on how we can give kids (and adults) concrete
> experiences with the concept of fraction.
You do not have to give them such experiences. You need to draw attention to the experiences they have had all their lives.
You do eat slices of pie, cake, and pizza, and chocolate bars marked for breaking, I trust. You use coins, and can get dollar coins, half dollars, quarters, tenths, twentieths, and hundredths. [Or Euros, pesos, and so on for other countries.] You can talk about the divisions of hours, minutes, seconds, yards, feet, inches, meters, decimeters, centimeters, gallons, quarts, pints, cups, fluid ounces, tablespoons, teaspoons, liters, milliliters, pounds, ounces, kilograms, grams…
> Special bonus points for anyone who can come up with an example of
> division with fractions (ex: 1/3 divided by 1/2)
1/2 goes into 1 twice. In fact it goes into any whole number N by dividing N objects into 2 pieces each, giving 2N pieces. Similarly, it goes into 1/3 twice 1/3, or 2/3. If you divide a circle into sixths, you can easily see that a third of the circle (two pieces) is two-thirds of half the circle (three pieces), in just the same way that, for example, two beads is 1/4 of eight beads.
It has been done in detail, and is available on various OER sites, some of which are [listed in the Sugar Labs Wiki].
I have written about this on other mailing lists. I will do a Turtle Art version of this some time soon, after I do a bit more on the concept I have been working on most recently, Figurate Numbers. [and, as it turns out, Counting, and Visual Numerals, and the J programming language…] I have several such lessons [in the Sugar Labs wiki].
Tony Forster did a TA visualization for fractions that I plan to carry further.
Others are welcome to join with Tony and me.
So here is the outline. You will have to take this more slowly with children, of course.
- Cut a pie in pieces, and color some of the pieces, as Tony did. That gives the basic idea of a fraction. Point out that when you cut a pie in, say, 8 pieces, you are doing 1 divided by 1/8.
- Cut more than one pie in the same number of pieces each. This lets us talk about “improper” fractions and mixed fractions (integer plus fraction), and converting between them. We can also introduce rational numbers at some stage of child development.
- Cut a pie in pieces, and cut the pieces into smaller pieces (multiplication of the simplest fractions, such as 1/2 times 1/3). Some fractions can be described using the bigger pieces, and some require the smaller pieces. Talk about reducing fractions to lowest terms. (You will need other materials in order to talk about Greatest Common Divisors. I’ll do something on that.) Take some time on multiplying fractions. Then notice that, for example, if you divide a pie into sixths, three of the pieces make a half. 3 times 1/6 is 1/2, so 1/2 divided by 3 is 1/6, and 1/2 (= 3/6) divided by 1/6 is 3. (Assuming prior understanding that if the product of, say, 2 and 3 is 6, then 6/3 = 2 and 6/2 = 3.)
- Cut several pies. For example, cut two pies into three pieces each, and then color pairs of pieces. How many groups of two pieces make two pies? Congratulations, you have just divided 2 by 2/3.
- Work other examples, dividing whole numbers by fractions, then fractions by other fractions, choosing cases that come out even to start with.
- Now look at examples where one fraction does not go evenly into the other. What do you have to do to make sense of the remainder? Say you have a pizza cut into 8 pieces, and you have hungry pizza eaters who want three slices each. How many can you accommodate? Well, two, with two slices left over. Two slices is 2/3 of three slices, so [1 divided by 3/8] comes to [8/3, or] 2 2/3 portions.
None of this requires Turtle Art. You can cut pies or cakes, or pieces of construction paper to do all of this. Oh, yes. How many pieces do the local pizza parlors cut pizzas into? What fractions can you make from those pieces? Can you find pictures of pizzas from directly above, so that they appear as circles? (Yes.) What else? Craters on the moon? The whole moon? Circular swimming pools, fountains, ponds?
It remains an open question whether the children can discover the invert-and-multiply rule for dividing fractions by themselves, whether they will need broad hints, or whether they will have to be told. It would be interesting to me to hear how they would explain these ideas to each other. I will be interested to hear your results.
> IAEP — It’s An Education Project (not a laptop project!)
Edward Mokurai (默雷/धर्ममेघशब्दगर्ज/دھرممیگھشبدگر ج) Cherlin
Silent Thunder is my name, and Children are my nation.
The Cosmos is my dwelling place, the Truth my destination.